Scotia Global Asset Management Investor Sentiment Survey highlights the need for financial advice.

Investors' confidence slow to recover, but a financial plan improves outlook

Key messages

  • Canadians are feeling the pressure of higher living expenses on their investments, but research suggests professional advice and a financial plan can bring a significant confidence boost.
  • Nearly 6 in 10 (58%) of respondents are concerned, worried or anxious about their investments.
  • Those with a financial plan and those who have met with an advisor are more likely to view the current investment climate as a good time to invest.

Canadian investors continue to be wary of risks in the current economic climate and are concerned about falling short of retirement goals, our most recent Scotia Global Asset Management Investor Sentiment Survey shows.

At the same time, our findings suggest that investors who meet regularly with an advisor and those who have a financial plan are more likely to have a positive outlook, prioritize savings and stay focused on their retirement goal.      

The online survey, conducted in November 2023 by Environics Research, included 1,028 Canadians, age 25 or older with investable assets of at least $25,000 and who participate in household investment decisions. The data was weighted by region, demographics and investable assets to reflect the wider population.

Key finding: Most feel sombre about their investments, but getting advice improves their outlook

More than half of Canadians (58%) remain pessimistic about their investments, a sentiment holding steady from our previous survey in January 2023 (59%).

The risks of rising inflation and a possible recession were top concerns to the health of portfolios over the next two years. Nearly one in five respondents (19%) also expect to decrease contributions to their investments in the next year, with many feeling the pinch of increased household expenses.

Nearly half (47%) felt it was neither a good time nor a bad time to invest in the current climate, underscoring the value of seeking out professional advice.

Graphic comparing how respondents felt about their investments in November 2023 versus January 2023. 23% felt positive about their investments in November 2023 versus 22%. 58% felt negative about their investments in November 2023 versus 59%.
Graphic illustrating the top 5 concerns for investors: Rising inflation at 52%, recession at 52%, rising interest rates at 39%, stock market volatility at 36% and geopolitical risks at 33%.

Advice makes a difference: Despite sombre sentiment, nearly a quarter of all respondents (23%) felt positive about their investments and more than a third of respondents believe it is a good time to invest (36%). Those who are more likely to view the current investment climate as a good time to invest include those who have a financial plan (52%).

Among those who work with an advisor, two-thirds (65%) agree that their advisor helps them avoid making mistakes when buying and selling investments. This suggests that having a plan and working with an advisor can provide discipline to hold course through challenging times.

Market volatility can be unsettling and can lead to impulsive decisions that may not align with long-term financial goals. For instance, those who retreated or held back on investments last year due to uncertainty may have missed the strong year-end rally that accounted for much of the year’s gains. As highlighted in our 2023 Year in Review, most major indices defied expectations and reached new highs in 2023, bringing double digit returns.

Graphic illustrating how financial planning can improve an investor’s view on the investment climate. Respondents with a financial plan are more likely to see the current investment climate as net good, 52%, versus those without a financial plan, 25%. Respondents with a financial plan are less likely to see the current investment climate as net bad, 6%, versus those without a financial plan 15%.
Graphic illustrating how investors value working with an advisor. Of those that work with an advisor, 65% agree that their advisor helps them avoid making mistakes when buying and selling investments. 25% are indifferent, 8% disagree and 2% don’t know or are not sure.

Key finding: Less certain about funding retirement, Canadians seek reassurance

As the rising cost of living has squeezed budgets, inflation is also making some investors feel less certain about their retirement plans. Canadians' confidence in their ability to fund retirement declined from our previous survey period, from 81% in January 2023, down to 77% in November 2023.

Six in 10 (60%) respondents say that current economic conditions have impacted their retirement plans.

Being able to withdraw a specific monthly dollar amount in retirement was the most common financial focus for just over one third (34%) of investors who are not yet retired. 

Graphic comparing how respondents feel about their ability to fund retirement in November 2023 versus January 2023 and Fall 2021. Very confident decreased from 37% in Fall 2021 to 34% in January 2023 to 29% in November 2023. Somewhat confident went from 45% to 47% to 48%. Not confident went from 13% to 13% to 15%. Not at all confident when from 2% to 4% to 5%.
Graphic illustrating the top retirement financial goals: Achieving a monthly income target at 34%, achieving a target value at 25%, replacing a percentage of pre-retirement income at 24% and don’t know at 16%.

Positive impact of financial plans: Developing a personal financial plan can help ease concerns about short term market conditions, by including assumptions that anticipate ups and downs in performance and inflation.

Those with financial plans are more likely to say that saving is still a priority for them despite higher living costs (78%) compared to those who don't (67%), according to our survey.

If you have doubts, it can make sense to meet with an advisor for a portfolio check-up and to revisit objectives. Those who prioritize monthly income at the top of retirement savings goals may benefit from strategies that can position a portfolio to pay out enough income to live comfortably in retirement. 

Graphic illustrating how having a financial plan can keep you on track towards retirement despite rising costs. Respondents with a financial plan are less likely to find it difficult to save for the future, 60% find it harder to save for the future versus 66%. Respondents with a financial plan continue to prioritize savings, 78% still prioritize savings versus 67%. Respondents with a financial plan are more concerned about how inflation will impact retirement savings, 74% are concerned versus 70%.

Key finding: Working with an advisor raises confidence and improves outlook

The most confident investors in our survey were more likely to have a written financial plan and meet regularly with a trusted advisor.

A steady seven in 10 Canadians say they work with a financial advisor to help manage their investments. But those who met more frequently, during the previous six months, tended to have more confidence in their advisors and be twice as likely to have a written financial plan.

Canadians who met with an advisor in the prior six months are also more likely to describe a positive sentiment towards their investments and agree that their advisor keeps them on track to meet goals.

Graphic illustrating how meeting with an advisor regularly can make you feel more confident. 85% of respondents who met with advisor in the past six months feel the advisor understands their needs and makes appropriate recommendations versus 68% who did not meet with their advisor. 80% feel that the advisor makes them feel confident about their financial situation versus 61%. 78% feel that the advisor keeps them on track to meet their goals versus 57%.
Graphic illustrating how meeting with an advisor can improve an investors outlook about their investments. Of the respondents with positive feelings about their investments, 28% had met with an advisor within the last six months and 15% had not met with an advisor in the last six months.

Relying on help for decision-making: More than three quarters of people who work with an advisor (77%) agree that their advisor understands their needs and makes appropriate recommendations. And 72% say their primary advisor makes them feel confident about their financial situation.

About half of those who have a financial plan have a positive view of the investment climate and their expectation of returns.

Working regularly with an advisor may help boost investor confidence in several ways. Your advisor can help put uncertainty in context with a long-term outlook, put the day-to-day market headlines into perspective, and help you stick to your investment strategy.

Graphic illustrating how investors with a financial plan have more optimistic expectations for investment performance. Respondents expecting higher returns that in prior 12 months, 47% have financial plans, 30% do not. Respondents expecting about the same returns as prior 12 months, 38% have financial plans, 49% do not. Respondents expecting lower returns than in prior 12 months, 14% have a financial plan, 21% do not.

Boost your confidence with a check in

While economic and market conditions will inevitably change from year to year, the Scotia Global Asset Management Investor Sentiment Survey has consistently found that investors feel more confident in reaching their goals when they work with an advisor and have a financial plan in place.

These investors are also more likely to feel like their goals are on track and maintain a better outlook through difficult markets.

If you’re feeling uncertain about your financial future or how well you’re progressing towards retirement and investment goals, it can be reassuring to meet with an advisor.

Whether you're concerned about how the cost of living may affect your portfolio or you want to review savings and retirement strategies, your advisor can work with you to stay on track to reach your financial goals.

Reach out to your Scotiabank advisor or book an appointment today.

Related content

decorative

Investing through 2024 and beyond with robust portfolios 

 

We examine the short-term and long-term considerations for our clients' portfolios. Let's compare our 12-month and 10-year perspectives. Learn more.

decorative

5 timeless tips on managing market ups and downs

 

In this article we provide you with some tips on how to manage - and potentially benefit from - market volatility.

decorative

2023 in Review: 5 essential investing lessons

Read about the key investing lessons from 2023 and learn time-tested investing strategies to help set yourself up for success in the new year and beyond.